Online heart age test in just nonsense, health chiefs are told amid fears they are needlessly scaring people
- Public Health England launched campaign urging people to take its online test
- But leading scientists have criticised the Heart Age Test as ‘ridiculous’
- They say it can overestimate a person’s heart age if – like most – the individual does not happen to know their cholesterol levels and blood pressure readings
Stephen Adams Health Correspondent For The Mail On Sunday
Health bosses have been accused of needlessly scaring people into believing they could suffer an early heart attack or stroke.
Last Tuesday, Public Health England launched a major campaign urging people over 30 to take its online Heart Age Test, warning that ‘four out of five people have a heart age higher than their actual age’.
The initiative generated huge publicity, with the BBC giving it prominent coverage.
In a promotional tweet, PHE stated: ‘Did you know, having a heart age older than your actual age means you are at a greater risk of having a heart attack or stroke?’
Health bosses have been accused of needlessly scaring people into believing they could suffer an early heart attack or stroke
But leading scientists have criticised the Heart Age Test as ‘ridiculous’ and ‘evidence-free nonsense’.
They say it can overestimate a person’s heart age if – like most – the individual does not happen to know their cholesterol levels and blood pressure readings.
In the absence of these readings, the test simply calculates an individual’s heart age using information the person has given including date of birth, height, weight, known health conditions and family history of cardiovascular disease.
It then plugs in the gaps for cholesterol and blood pressure using national averages. This can result in the assumption that the individual’s heart is in a worse condition than is the case.
Dr Ben Goldacre, author of the book Bad Science, wrote on Twitter: ‘This test is ridiculous. Try it. PHE’s tool tells a woman in her 30s that her heart age is older than her real age because she’s not had her cholesterol done. And tells her to get her cholesterol done by [going to see her] GP.’
Last Tuesday, Public Health England launched a major campaign urging people over 30 to take its online Heart Age Test
A spot test by a 43-year-old male gave a heart age of 41 when he entered all his details including cholesterol and blood pressure. When he omitted these readings, his heart age shot up five years to 46.
Reader Pat Powell, from Cardiff, said: ‘I took the online test without including my blood pressure or cholesterol readings. My heart age came out as 10 years older than I am. When I re-did the test with my blood pressure and cholesterol readings, my heart age was spot on. Is this test just scaremongering?’
At the end of the Heart Age Test, people who did not enter their cholesterol or blood pressure readings are advised: ‘Make an appointment with your doctor, nurse or pharmacist to get your blood pressure and cholesterol tested.’ Dr Goldacre said this advice could result in tens of thousands of perfectly healthy people in their 30s booking ‘totally unnecessary GP consultations’ at considerable expense to the NHS.
He feared PHE was prioritising media impact and public engagement over producing a rigorous test that gave meaningful results.
Fellow science writer Professor Tim Spector, author of The Diet Myth, weighed in: ‘More evidence-less nonsense from PHE.’
Others pointed out that the Heart Age Test, which is a collaboration between PHE, the British Heart Foundation and University College London, takes no account of how much exercise an individual does.
But Professor Jamie Waterall, PHE’s national lead for cardiovascular disease prevention, dismissed the criticism.
He said there was ‘no evidence to suggest’ the test would create extra demand for GPs, adding: ‘What we have seen is a big increase in people accessing lifestyle information, which is fantastic.
‘High blood pressure and high cholesterol are two major causes of heart attack and stroke but millions don’t know they are affected, so the test encourages anyone that doesn’t know their blood pressure and cholesterol levels to find out.
‘The Heart Age Test has strong clinical and academic support as it is based on guidelines from Joint British Societies recommendations on the prevention of cardiovascular disease.’
-
![In the poll of 2,000 office workers, 39 per cent said the lavatory was the best place for ‘peace and quiet’, with an average of around 14 minutes spent in the toilets each day]()
In loo of an office break… One in three employees pop…
-
![The long-awaited recommendations from the Commission on Religious Education suggest a number of changes (file photo)]()
RE lessons should incorporate worldviews to all pupils to…
-
![Dangerous criminals who breach strict rules after being released from jail are being spared lengthy terms in order to keep the prison population down]()
Dangerous criminals who breach strict rules after being…
-
![A survey of more than 2,000 people revealed two thirds of residents row with neighbours over their outdoor etiquette (file photo)]()
Everything’s coming up rowdy in UK garden wars: Two…
-
![Highly paid GPs have been accused of driving up waiting times by favouring lucrative private clients over their NHS patients (stock photo)]()
Can’t get in to see your doctor? Highly paid GPs accused…
-
![Macbre ¿mourning kits¿ have been sent out by a council in a ¿tasteless¿ preparation for the deaths of the Queen, Prince Philip and Prince Charles]()
Council blasted over macabre ‘mourning kits’ that include…
-
![Crime tsar Alison Hernandez has privately been recovering from the ordeal of an abusive relationship that lasted more than two years]()
Top crime tsar reveals violent ex-boyfriend convinced her…
-
![Drivers of electric and hydrogen cars would potentially be allowed to use bus or 'green' vehicle lanes through town centres with special green number plates fitted to 'clean' cars]()
Drivers of ‘clean’ cars will be able to show off their…
-
![A payout limit of £500,000 to victims of terrorist attacks could be raised under Government plans, according to Justice Secretary David Gauke]()
Terror attack victims could receive £500,000 under new…
-
![The discovery on the Llyn Peninsula in North West Wales (file photo) is so sensitive its exact location is being kept secret. It came to light after aerial photos revealed lines of brown grass]()
Heatwave lets slip Romans had plans to invade Ireland:…
-
![Monkeypox, A Member Of The Orthopox Family Of Viruses, Is An Infection Accidentally Transmitted To Human]()
Deadly virus monkeypox found the UK for the first time as…
-
![British sports car firm Aston Martin is launching an SUV next year (pictured) designed mainly for women]()
Aston Martina! Bond’s favourite car maker targets women…
-
![Labour MP Joan Ryan, (Enfield North), lost a vote of confidence yesterday by three votes]()
Labour probing claims two Iranian sympathisers…
-
![Builders spend nearly two years of their working lives eating their lunch, six months making cups of tea and nearly a year hunting for the right tool]()
Builders spend nearly two YEARS of their working lives…
-
![Vick Hope and Graziano Di Prima on BBC's Strictly Come Dancing this week]()
Capital DJ Vick Hope lands Strictly’s new Italian…
-
![Police said a man was taken to hospital after the attack on Bensham Lane, Croydon (pictured) on Saturday. His condition is not currently known and no arrests have been made]()
Man in his 30s stabbed multiple times in Croydon as…
-
![A non-stop Qantas flight from Perth to London on Saturday night was forced to turn back two hours after take-off due to a disruptive male passenger (pictured QF10)]()
Non-stop Qantas flight from Perth to London is forced to…
-
![Shadow Chancellor John McDonnell giving out anti-Israel leaflets to 'secure peace']()
‘Don’t sell Israeli goods’: Shadow Chancellor John…
Comments 15
Share what you think
-
Newest -
Oldest -
Best rated -
Worst rated
The comments below have not been moderated.
The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.
Close
Do you want to automatically post your MailOnline comments to your Facebook Timeline?
Your comment will be posted to MailOnline as usual.
Close
Do you want to automatically post your MailOnline comments to your Facebook Timeline?
Your comment will be posted to MailOnline as usual
We will automatically post your comment and a link to the news story to your Facebook timeline at the same time it is posted on MailOnline. To do this we will link your MailOnline account with your Facebook account. We’ll ask you to confirm this for your first post to Facebook.
You can choose on each post whether you would like it to be posted to Facebook. Your details from Facebook will be used to provide you with tailored content, marketing and ads in line with our Privacy Policy.
Article source: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-6147307/Online-heart-age-test-just-nonsense-health-chiefs-told.html